Message us on WhatsApp
    All comparisons
    Comparison

    EDI vs Web Portal: When Manual Order Entry Is Enough

    Every major retailer has its own web portal where suppliers can download orders and upload dispatch advices/invoices manually. It works for small volumes, but becomes an operational nightmare at 5+ retailers or over 30 orders/day.

    CriterionEDI integrated with ERPRetailer's manual web portal
    Number of portals to manage
    1 (EDIconnect)
    One portal per retailer (5–15)
    Separate accounts & passwords
    Single login
    Separate login for every retailer
    ERP integration
    Native (40+ ERPs)
    None (manual copy-paste)
    Time per order
    Automated
    5–10 minutes manual per portal
    Centralized notifications
    Single dashboard
    Email/SMS from every portal
    Availability SLA
    99.9% (EDIconnect)
    Varies per retailer
    Monthly cost
    From €15/month (connection per retailer billed separately)
    €0 (but FTE cost: €600–1200/month)
    Score7 criteria won0 criteria won

    Verdict

    Retailer web portals are acceptable only if you work with 1–2 retailers and under 10 orders/day. Above that threshold, EDIconnect consolidates everything into one portal with ERP integration, eliminating operational complexity.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can I use the retailer's portal in parallel with EDIconnect?

    Yes, but it isn't recommended. EDIconnect already delivers all the retailer portal's features + ERP integration + a centralized dashboard across all retailers.

    What happens if the retailer's portal has downtime?

    With EDIconnect, EDI messages are stored and automatically retransmitted when the connection is back (AS2/VAN store-and-forward). With a web portal, downtime = lost orders.

    Can I stop using the retailer's portal entirely?

    Yes, once EDIconnect is certified with the retailer. Everything you used to do manually in the portal (downloading orders, uploading invoices) runs automatically via EDI.